Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Martin Bulmer in New Zealand on how we read and don't read in this new PAPER vs SCREEN Age....


Martin Bulmer currently lives in New Zealand where he serves as General Manager, Wellington Office at NV Interactive. In addition, he twitters at Toa5t and occasionally posts at Boxes and Arrows. He has more than 15 years experience as a business-focused Internet professional offering specialist skills and depth of experience in user experience, user interface design and information architecture (IA) as well as consultative sales, developing digital strategies, innovation and problem solving. He also has beaucoup experience running web teams and web projects.


So Zippy13oo was pleased to see Martin's comment at Boxes and Arrows recently, which he also tweeted about, saying, in response to this blog's ongoing research into the differences between reading on paper and reading on screens:

MARTIN BULMER: Hi Zippy1300! All I can say is that the comment system of B+A sure discourages reading from screen. Yes, we'll be reading from paper. if for no other reason than it'll still be around; there's just too much value in them thar pages. BUT paper, generally, does not run out of batteries, can respond well to serious abuse (being dropped, wetted, folded, torn, stuck back together, written on and thumbed repeatedly) and has a number of useful cues and affordances. You can tell how far through the book you are; you can use this method to estimate your position should you drop the bookmark. you can scan the pages quickly because you remember quite a lot about the shape of paragraphs. Being reflective rather than luminant it is more often than not easer on the eye. Most importantly, these sorts of cues don't have to be taught explicitly; they come as baggage with the teaching of reading. I don't know about you, but if I switch off my concious focus when reading on screen I have to go back and read again; it seems to require 'active reading'. Reading a book on the other hand is more often refered to as 'relaxing'... I'd be very surprised if different parts of the brain didn't light up..."

2 Comments:

Blogger dan said...

Martin, thanks for your comments above. You are the first person here to take the time to comment and to take my ideas seriously. I appreciate your good feedback. If you want to keep up with my evolving thinking on this, and I do not hav a PHD or anything, just a common thinker thinking hard about this, because it matters, go to my blog at "zippy1300" in the blogosphere. you can find it via Google. Let me underline what i like about what you said: IN CAPS All I can say is that the comment system of B+A sure discourages reading from screen. HAHA Yes we'll be reading from paper. if for no other reason than it'll still be around; there's just too much value in them thar pages. I DO HOPE SO. .....paper, generally, does not run out of batteries, can respond well to serious abuse (being dropped, wetted, folded, torn, stuck back together, written on and thumbed repeatedly) and has a number of useful cues and affordances. ... GOOD POINT THERE re CUES AND AFFORADANCES.... I LIKE THAT You can tell how far through the book you are; IMPORTANT YES you can use this method to estimate your position should you drop the bookmark. SMILE you can scan the pages quickly because you remember quite a lot about the shape of paragraphs.EXACTLY. WELL SAID Being reflective rather than luminant, it is more often than not easer on the eye. TELL ME! Most importantly, these sorts of cues don't have to be taught explicitly; they come as baggage with the teaching of reading. VERY WELL SAID I don't know about you, but if I switch off my concious focus when reading on screen ME TOO. THAT IS WHY I STARTED THIKING ABOUT THIS. I HATE SCREEENING BUT I DO IT FOR EMAIL AND NEWS BITS BUT FOR ANYTHING LONG I MUST PRINT IT OUT AND READ IT ON PAPER. THAT got me to thinking,,,, I have to go back and read again; it seems to require 'active reading'. I HATE THESE SCREENS FOR READING. FOR VIDEOS AND MOVIES and HEADLINE NEWS, sure.BUT.... Reading a book on the other hand is more often refered to as 'relaxing'... YES YES YES I'd be very surprised if different part of the brain didn't light up. TIS IS WHAT I WANT TO EXPLORE. OR I MEAN THIS IS WHAT I HOPE PHD SCIENTISTS WILL START EXPLORING SO WE HAV SOME REAL EVIDENCE...... PRO AND CON

9:35 PM  
Blogger Alparslan said...

Sesli Sohbet Sesli Chat Diyet Makyaj Sesli Sohbet Sesli Chat Güzel Sözler Aşk sözleri Aşk mesajları Etkileyici Sözler Günaydın Mesajları Video izle aşk şiirleri Aşk sözleri Güzel Aşk sözleri Aşk mesajları Msn Nickleri Msn Nickleri Radyo Dinle oyun Güvenlik Sistemleri Kamelya Wushu şiir aşk resimleri Güzel Sözler Aşk mesajları Yeni Aşk Sözleri Hazır Sözler aşk şiiri çok güzel sözler Sesli Sohbet Sesli Chat Sesli Sohbet Sesli Chat

2:45 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home